However, it was Modi's
meeting with Facebook chief executive Mark Zuckerberg that was keenly
watched by India because of the contentious internet. org initiative of
the social network. Facebook's internet. org, which was renamed "Free
Basics" just before the Modi visit, aims to provide free access to basic
Internet services by partnering with telecom companies.
Such
practices, commonly referred to as "zero-rating", allows users to access
select applications or websites, free of data charges, by striking
deals with telecom operators.
"Any endeavor that promotes
Digital India should in no uncertain terms be at odds with the spirit of
an open internet," said Patel in the letter.
The net neutrality
dialogue in India has hotly debated zero-rating practices which are seen
as a "walled garden" that would provide selective Internet access to
people who sign up.
Though the government did not take an
explicit stand on zero-rating or internet.org during the visit, a
controversy erupted in India when Facebook's launch of a profile picture
tool to support the Digital India programme was seen as supporting
internet.org.
"It's important to remember that Digital India
should first be about public interest," said Chinmayi Arun, research
director at the Center for Communication
Governance at National Law University. "After that, if any industry is
to benefit from the infrastructure, then the government should see it as
an opportunity for growth of Indian industry," she added.
Some,
however did not see anything amiss. "India's first BJP government
enabled Indian poor to get access to mobile telephony at prices they can
afford and its second could provide Indians with an Internet that
reflects the world's largest democracy's commitment to equality and
human dignity," said Mishi Choudhary, Legal Director, Software Freedom
Law Centre.
"Prime Minister Modi's visit to Silicon Valley is to make that possible," she added.
During
the visit, Zuckerberg, Modi, Minister Prasad and several other Facebook
executives covered their Facebook profile pictures in the tricolour to
show support for the Digital India initiative. Facebook had rolled out
internet. org in India last year with telecom operator Reliance, and
came under fire from several quarters who said the initiative violates
the principle of net neutrality or enabling equal Internet access for
everyone. "We should not be thinking of access to the Internet in terms
of binaries- that we either subscribe to internet.org or not.
The
question to ask is how to bridge the digital divide by best possible
means, by free access to all information online, with no single company
or institution playing gatekeeper," said CCG's Arun.
In a letter addressed to Communications and IT
minister Ravi Shankar Prasad, senior Congress leader Ahmed Patel said
making Internet access universal should not be "held hostage by a few
foreign corporations". Modi met Facebook, Microsoft, Tesla and Cisco
among others during his visit to the Silicon Valley, and sought their
support for the Digital India initiative - the Rs 1.13 lakh crore
programm which seeks to "transform the country into a digitally
empowered society and knowledge economy".
Hours after Prime Minister Narendra Modi landed in India after his
maiden Silicon Valley visit, the Opposition has attacked the
government's apparent inclination towards Facebook's controversial
internet.org programm, fanning the debate around net neutrality, which
they feel may be compromised in a bid to realise Digital India's
objectives.